The Bachelor Nation is still shaken from all of the drama that took place on the two part finale of The Bachelor.
Twitter fans of the reality show have pointed out that the ring Benoit Beausejour-Savard gave Clare Crawley on the Bachelor Winter Games‘ World Tells All special looks exactly like the one Arie gave Becca Kufrin on The Bachelor’s Final Rose.
Did Clare Crawley get Becca’s leftover engagement ring?
The Neil Lane sparklers are similar styles, but they’re two distinct pieces of jewelry.
“Both are handmade, and although similar in design, they are not the same ring,” Lane tells PEOPLE. “On first glance they do look similar.”
Becca’s ring features a center diamond weighing in at over 2 carats, surrounded by 84 on the halo and around the band for a total weight of over 3 carats.
Clare’s ring is also set with a central oval cut diamond, which is over 1 carat, plus 84 smaller round diamonds around the stone and band for a total weight of over 2 carats.